RENAISSANCE CRITICISM (16th-17th Century)

HISTORICAL CONTEXT

AspectDetails
PeriodLate 15th to early 17th century
Meaning"Rebirth" - revival of classical learning and values
Key Features• Humanism (man as center)
• Return to Greek/Roman classics
• Vernacular literature defense
• Rise of printing press
• Reformation's influence
Critical FocusDefense of poetry against Puritan attacks, establishing vernacular literature's legitimacy
MCQ AlertRenaissance = "Rebirth" of classical learning, NOT invention of new ideas

SIR PHILIP SIDNEY (1554-1586)

An Apologie for Poetrie / The Defence of Poesy (1595, posthumous)

TopicKey Points
PublicationWritten c. 1579-1580, published 1595 after Sidney's death
Two titles: "Apologie" (Ponsonby) & "Defence" (Olney)
OccasionResponse to Stephen Gosson's "School of Abuse" (1579) - Puritan attack on poetry as lies, immorality, waste of time
Structure1. Exordium (introduction)
2. Proposition (poetry's antiquity & universality)
3. Division (definition of poetry)
4. Examination (poetry vs. philosophy & history)
5. Refutation (answering charges)
6. Digression (English poetry's state)
7. Peroration (conclusion)
MCQ HotspotGosson's "School of Abuse" (1579) triggered Sidney's Defence

Sidney's Definition of Poetry

ConceptExplanation
Famous Definition"Poetry is an art of imitation, for so Aristotle termeth it in his word mimesis, that is to say, a representing, counterfeiting, or figuring forth"
Poet's RolePoet does NOT reproduce nature exactly but creates a "golden world" superior to nature's "brazen world"
Golden vs. BrazenBrazen World: Nature as it is (imperfect, fallen)
Golden World: Poetry's ideal, perfected vision
"Nature's world is brazen, the poets only deliver a golden"
Creative FreedomPoet is not bound by nature - creates things "better than Nature bringeth forth"
Poet as MakerFrom Greek "poiein" (to make) - poet is CREATOR, not mere imitator

Poetry Superior to Philosophy and History

ComparisonSidney's Argument
vs. PhilosophyPhilosopher: Gives precepts (abstract rules) - difficult, dry
Poet: Gives examples (concrete images) - delightful, memorable
• Philosophy teaches through gnosis (knowledge)
• Poetry teaches through praxis (action/example)
vs. HistoryHistorian: Bound to particular facts (what happened)
Poet: Free to show universal truths (what should happen)
• History shows what IS
• Poetry shows what OUGHT TO BE
Famous Quote"The philosopher teacheth, but he teacheth obscurely... the historian... is so tied to the particular truth of things that his example draweth no necessary consequence"
Poet's AdvantageCombines philosophy's precept with history's example = teaching through delight
MCQ KeySidney places POET above both philosopher and historian

Purpose of Poetry: Teach and Delight

ConceptDetails
Ultimate End"To teach and delight" (echoes Horace's dulce et utile)
Final PurposeMove readers to virtuous action - "to lead and draw us to as high a perfection as our degenerate souls... can be capable of"
MethodDelight: Sweet pill to make medicine go down
Teaching: Moral and intellectual improvement
Moving: Inspiring virtuous action (most important)
Famous Phrase"The ending end of all earthly learning being virtuous action"
Exam FocusSidney's tripartite: TEACH + DELIGHT + MOVE to virtuous action

Refutation of Charges Against Poetry

ChargeSidney's Defense
1. Poetry is waste of timeFALSE - Poetry teaches virtue and moral truth efficiently through delight
2. Poetry is mother of liesFALSE - Poet "nothing affirms, therefore never lieth"
Poet doesn't claim to present literal truth, but ideal truth
"What child is there that... will not believe the tales of poets?"
3. Poetry inspires immoralityFALSE - Abuse of poetry ≠ poetry itself
"Though right use is commended, abuse is to be suffered"
Blaming poetry for immorality is like blaming sword for murder
4. Plato banished poetsPlato banished ABUSES of poetry, not poetry itself
Plato himself used poetic dialogues
Plato objected to poets who misrepresented gods
Famous Quote"The poet nothing affirms, and therefore never lieth" - poetry presents fiction, not factual claims

Kinds of Poetry (Sidney's Classification)

TypeDescriptionExamples
1. Divine PoetryReligious, scriptural versePsalms of David, Song of Solomon
2. Philosophical PoetryMoral/natural philosophy in verseLucretius, Virgil's Georgics
3. Historical PoetryVerse chroniclesLucan's Pharsalia
4. Right PoetryMOST IMPORTANT - Creative fiction
Includes: Heroic, Lyric, Tragic, Comic, Satiric, Pastoral
Homer's Iliad, Virgil's Aeneid
Dramatic works
MCQ Alert"Right Poetry" = highest form for Sidney = creative/imaginative poetry

State of English Poetry (Sidney's Critique)

IssueSidney's Observation
ChaucerPraised as excellent, but language now outdated
The Mirror for MagistratesGood moral purpose but poetically weak
Earl of SurreyPraised for lyrical excellence and blank verse in English
Sackville & Norton"Gorboduc" - good tragedy but violates classical unities
Contemporary DramaMajor criticism: Violation of unities of time, place, action
"You shall have Asia of the one side, and Afric of the other"
Mixing kings and clowns inappropriately
Lyric PoetryToo much focus on love poetry; need more serious subjects
MCQ KeySidney criticizes English drama for violating classical UNITIES

Sidney's Significance

AchievementImpact
First Major English CriticismMost important English critical work before Dryden
Defense of Imaginative LiteratureEstablished poetry's legitimacy against Puritan attacks
SynthesisCombined classical (Aristotle, Horace) with Renaissance humanism
English VernacularElevated status of English as literary language
InfluenceShaped English critical tradition for centuries
RememberSIDNEY = Golden World + Teach & Delight + Nothing Affirms/Never Lies + Poetry > Philosophy & History

EDMUND SPENSER (1552/53-1599)

Critical Contributions

WorkContribution
The Shepheardes Calender (1579)Dedication to Sidney; preface by "E.K." discusses poetic language
Defense of archaic words and rustic diction
Established pastoral in English
Letter to Raleigh (1590)Appended to The Faerie Queene
Explains allegorical method and moral purpose
"To fashion a gentleman in virtuous and gentle discipline"
Poetic PracticeCreated Spenserian Stanza (ababbcbcc)
Revived archaic language for poetic effect
Allegorical method (moral, historical, personal levels)
MCQ AlertSpenser's stated purpose in Faerie Queene: "fashion a gentleman in virtuous and gentle discipline"

The Faerie Queene - Allegorical Method

AspectDetails
StructurePlanned 12 books (only 6 + fragment completed)
Each book = one knight = one virtue
The VirtuesBook I: Holiness (Red Cross Knight)
Book II: Temperance (Guyon)
Book III: Chastity (Britomart)
Book IV: Friendship (Cambell & Triamond)
Book V: Justice (Artegall)
Book VI: Courtesy (Calidore)
Triple Allegory1. Moral: Virtues and vices
2. Historical: Elizabeth I, contemporary events
3. Personal: Spenser's own experiences
ModelsCombined classical epic (Homer, Virgil) with medieval romance (Ariosto, Tasso)
GlorianaFaerie Queene = Queen Elizabeth = Glory = allegorical center
Exam KeySpenser uses TRIPLE allegory: Moral + Historical + Personal

Defense of Archaic Language (E.K.'s Preface)

PointArgument
Use of Old WordsArchaic language gives poetry "gravity" and "stateliness"
"Old words are most used of country folk"
Against Inkhorn TermsRejects foreign borrowings in favor of native English words
Prefers Anglo-Saxon over Latin/French
Poetic DecorumRustic language appropriate for pastoral poetry
Different genres require different linguistic registers
Chaucer's InfluenceSpenser seen as heir to Chaucer - reviving Middle English poetic tradition
MCQ PointE.K. defends Spenser's ARCHAISMS as giving poetry gravity and stateliness

Spenser's Significance

AchievementImpact
Poet's PoetCalled "The Poet's Poet" - influenced Milton, Keats, Romantics
Spenserian StanzaCreated influential 9-line stanza form (used by Byron, Shelley, Keats)
Allegory RevivalMade allegory sophisticated literary technique in English
English EpicFirst sustained English epic since medieval period
Language ShapingDemonstrated poetic potential of English vernacular
RememberSPENSER = Faerie Queene + Triple Allegory + Fashion a Gentleman + Spenserian Stanza + Archaisms

OTHER RENAISSANCE CRITICS

CriticWork/Contribution
George PuttenhamThe Arte of English Poesie (1589)
Rhetoric manual; defense of English as poetic language
Discusses figures of speech, poetic ornament
George GascoigneCertayne Notes of Instruction (1575)
First English treatise on poetry writing
Technical advice on meter, rhyme, invention
Samuel DanielA Defence of Rhyme (1603)
Against Thomas Campion's attack on rhyme
Defends English rhymed verse vs. classical quantitative meter
Ben JonsonTimber, or Discoveries (1640, posthumous)
Commonplace book with critical observations
Neoclassical emphasis on rules, learning, imitation
MCQ AlertPuttenham's Arte of English Poesie (1589) = major Renaissance rhetoric/poetics manual

RENAISSANCE CRITICISM - KEY THEMES

ThemeExplanation
Defense PostureMuch criticism written to DEFEND poetry against moral/religious attacks
Vernacular LegitimacyEstablishing English as worthy literary language (not just Latin/Greek)
Classical RevivalReturn to Aristotle, Horace - but adapted to Christian context
Moral DidacticismPoetry must teach virtue - NOT just entertain
Imitation DebateShould poets imitate classics or create original works?
How does "imitation" relate to creativity?
DecorumAppropriateness of style to subject, genre, characters
Unities QuestionShould English drama follow Aristotelian unities?
Sidney says YES; later practice says NO
Memory AidRenaissance = DEFENSE + VERNACULAR + CLASSICAL REVIVAL + MORAL PURPOSE

MCQ RAPID FIRE - Renaissance Criticism

Question TypeAnswer
Sidney's work responding to GossonAn Apologie for Poetrie / Defence of Poesy (1595)
Gosson's attack on poetryThe School of Abuse (1579)
Nature's world vs. poet's worldBrazen world vs. Golden world
Sidney's definition of poetry"Art of imitation" (mimesis) - representing/figuring forth
Poet's advantage over philosopherTeaches through delightful EXAMPLES, not dry precepts
Poet's advantage over historianShows universal truth (what ought to be), not just particular facts
"Poet nothing affirms...""...and therefore never lieth" - Sidney's defense
Sidney's ultimate purpose of poetryMove to virtuous action (teach + delight + move)
Highest form of poetry for Sidney"Right Poetry" (creative/imaginative)
Sidney's critique of English dramaViolates classical unities of time, place, action
Spenser's purpose in Faerie Queene"To fashion a gentleman in virtuous and gentle discipline"
Spenser's stanza formSpenserian Stanza (ababbcbcc, 9 lines)
Spenser's nickname"The Poet's Poet"
Faerie Queene allegorical levelsMoral + Historical + Personal (triple allegory)
E.K.'s defense of archaic wordsGive poetry "gravity" and "stateliness"
Puttenham's poetics manualThe Arte of English Poesie (1589)
First English critical treatise on poetry writingGascoigne's Certayne Notes of Instruction (1575)
Defense of rhyme against classical meterSamuel Daniel's A Defence of Rhyme (1603)