ECOCRITICISM & CULTURAL STUDIES

ECOCRITICISM (1990s-Present)

Overview

AspectDetails
Emergence1990s (term coined by Cheryll Glotfelty, 1990s)
Formalized with ASLE (Association for Study of Literature and Environment) 1992
Core PremiseStudy relationship between literature and physical environment
Earth-centered approach to literature
Environmental crisis requires new critical approach
"How do we read nature in texts?"
InterdisciplinaryLiterature + Ecology + Environmental Studies + Philosophy
Science + Humanities bridge
Political DimensionActivist orientation - environmental advocacy
NOT just academic - practical ecological concern
Raise environmental consciousness
MCQ AlertEcocriticism (1990s+) - literature-environment relationship; earth-centered

Key Figures & Foundational Texts

ScholarWork/Contribution
Rachel CarsonSilent Spring (1962) - precursor; environmental writing
Exposed pesticide dangers; catalyzed environmental movement
Joseph MeekerThe Comedy of Survival (1972) - early ecocritical work
"Literary ecology" - how literature affects ecological consciousness
Cheryll GlotfeltyEditor, The Ecocriticism Reader (1996) - landmark anthology
Defined field, established terminology
"Ecocriticism is the study of the relationship between literature and the physical environment"
Lawrence BuellThe Environmental Imagination (1995) - Thoreau, nature writing
The Future of Environmental Criticism (2005) - second-wave ecocriticism
Greg GarrardEcocriticism (2004) - comprehensive introduction
Key concepts: wilderness, apocalypse, dwelling, animals, earth
FoundationalGlotfelty's Ecocriticism Reader (1996) established field

Core Concepts

ConceptDetails
Nature as SubjectNature = NOT just setting/backdrop
Nature = active presence, character, agent
Move from anthropocentric to ecocentric reading
Attend to non-human perspectives
Anthropocentrism vs. EcocentrismAnthropocentrism: Human-centered worldview
• Humans = most important
• Nature = resource for human use
Ecocentrism: Ecology-centered
• Humans = part of ecosystem
• Nature has intrinsic value
Ecocriticism: Challenges anthropocentrism
WildernessContested concept:
• Romantic view: pristine, untouched nature
• Critical view: "wilderness" = cultural construct
• Indigenous peoples inhabited "wilderness"
• Idealizing wilderness can justify removal of people
PastoralLiterary mode idealizing rural life
Ecocritical question: Does pastoral help or harm?
• Positive: Connects readers to nature
• Negative: Romanticizes, simplifies ecology
Nostalgia vs. genuine ecological consciousness
Deep EcologyPhilosophical movement (Arne Naess)
All life forms have intrinsic value
Radical environmentalism
Influenced some ecocritics

Waves of Ecocriticism

WaveFocusCharacteristics
First Wave (1990s)Nature Writing & Wilderness
Focus: Romantic nature poetry, American nature writing (Thoreau, Muir)
Celebrate wilderness, rural landscapes
Realist approach to representation
• USA-centered
• Romantic tradition
• Non-fiction nature writing
• Wilderness preservation
• Somewhat essentialist about "nature"
Second Wave (2000s+)Urban, Global, Diverse
Focus: Urban environments, environmental justice, global perspectives
Postcolonial ecocriticism, toxic discourse
Constructivist about "nature"
• Global South perspectives
• Environmental justice (race, class)
• Urban ecology
• Toxicity, pollution
• Nature as cultural construct
• Science fiction, cli-fi
Third Wave (2010s+)Material Ecocriticism, Posthumanism
New materialism, object-oriented ontology
Agency of non-human entities
Anthropocene discourse
• Material turn
• Non-human agency
• Anthropocene
• Climate change
• Posthumanism
• Speculative fiction

Key Questions Ecocriticism Asks

QuestionPurpose
How is nature represented?Analyze textual constructions of "nature," environment
Is nature passive backdrop or active presence?
What role does setting play?Physical environment's impact on plot, character, theme
Not just context but constituent element
What values underlie representation?Anthropocentric vs. ecocentric?
Exploitative vs. sustainable?
Wilderness vs. garden vs. urban?
How does text shape consciousness?Does work promote environmental awareness?
Reinforce or challenge destructive attitudes?
Practical ecological impact?
Whose voices are heard?Human only, or non-human too?
Environmental justice - which communities affected?

Environmental Justice Ecocriticism

ConceptDetails
Environmental RacismToxic waste, pollution disproportionately affect communities of color
Environmental problems = social justice issues
Intersectionality: Race + Class + Environment
Eco-JusticeFair distribution of environmental benefits/burdens
Who has access to clean air, water, parks?
Literature of environmental struggle
TextsLiterature of protest, resistance
Toxic discourse - pollution narratives
Indigenous environmental writing
Key PointEnvironmental issues = NOT separate from social justice; deeply interconnected

Ecocriticism - Significance & Critique

AchievementCritique
New PerspectiveMade environment visible in literary studySometimes reductive - everything environmental?
Practical UrgencyResponds to real ecological crisis; activistToo activist? Blurs criticism and advocacy
InterdisciplinaryBridges humanities and sciencesRequires scientific knowledge critics lack?
Canon RevisionRecovered nature writing, expanded canonFirst wave too narrow (wilderness, USA)
Global ReachSecond wave: postcolonial, diverse perspectivesStill relatively recent, evolving

CULTURAL STUDIES (1960s-Present)

Overview

AspectDetails
Origins1960s Britain (Birmingham Centre for Contemporary Cultural Studies, 1964)
Founders: Richard Hoggart, Stuart Hall, Raymond Williams
Core PremiseStudy ALL cultural forms, not just "high" literature
Culture = "whole way of life" (Williams)
Popular culture = legitimate object of study
Power relations in cultural production/consumption
Marxist RootsBase/superstructure (complex)
Ideology, hegemony (Gramsci)
Culture = site of struggle
InterdisciplinarySociology + Literature + Media Studies + Anthropology + Politics
Crosses traditional boundaries
MCQ AlertCultural Studies (1960s+ Britain) - Birmingham Centre; all cultural forms, popular culture, power

Key Figures & Works

FigureContribution
Richard HoggartThe Uses of Literacy (1957) - working-class culture
Founded Birmingham CCCS (1964)
Analyzed mass culture's impact on working class
Raymond WilliamsCulture and Society (1958) - traced "culture" concept
The Long Revolution (1961) - cultural materialism
Keywords (1976) - examined cultural vocabulary
"Culture is ordinary" - culture = everyday life, not elite property
Stuart HallCCCS Director (1968-79) - most influential
Encoding/Decoding model
Identity, race, representation
Hegemony theory
Dick HebdigeSubculture: The Meaning of Style (1979) - punk, subcultures
Style as resistance, symbolic struggle
FoundationalBirmingham CCCS (1964) - Hoggart, Hall, Williams; working-class/popular culture focus

STUART HALL (1932-2014)

Encoding/Decoding Model (1973)

ConceptDetails
Model OverviewMedia messages: Encoded (produced) → Decoded (received)
Production ≠ Reception
Audience = active, not passive
Multiple readings possible
Three Decoding Positions1. Dominant/Hegemonic: Accept intended meaning
  • Reader accepts message as intended
2. Negotiated: Partly accept, partly resist
  • Accept general framework but adapt to own situation
3. Oppositional: Reject intended meaning
  • Understand but oppose; read "against the grain"
Most people = negotiated position
Active AudienceAudiences NOT cultural dupes
Interpret based on own social position
Meaning = negotiated, not imposed
Hall's ModelEncoding/Decoding - three positions: Dominant, Negotiated, Oppositional

Identity & Representation

ConceptDetails
Identity as ConstructedIdentity = NOT fixed essence
Constructed through representation
Multiple, fluid, contextual
"There is no essential black subject" - against essentialism
RepresentationHow cultures construct meaning through images, language
Representation = NOT mirror of reality
Representation = constitutive - creates reality
Power operates through representation
Race & EthnicityHall's work on black British identity
Diasporic identity - hybrid, multiple
Challenged essentialist notions of race

RAYMOND WILLIAMS (1921-1988)

ConceptDetails
"Culture is Ordinary"Culture = everyday life, not elite monopoly
Working-class culture = legitimate, valuable
Challenge high/low distinction
Democratic approach to culture
Cultural MaterialismMarxist approach to culture
Culture = material practice, not reflection
Base/superstructure too simplistic
Culture actively shapes social relations
Structure of FeelingShared social experience in particular time/place
NOT formal ideology but lived experience
Affective dimension of culture
How period "feels" - emergent meanings
Captured in literature, art before fully articulated
KeywordsKeywords (1976) - analyzed key cultural terms
Words like "culture," "class," "art," "industry"
Meanings change historically
Language = site of struggle
Famous Phrase"Culture is ordinary" + "Structure of Feeling"

Core Concepts of Cultural Studies

ConceptDetails
Hegemony (Gramsci)Dominant group's consent-based rule
NOT just force but consent
Common sense = hegemonic ideology
Can be challenged, contested
Culture = site of hegemonic struggle
SubcultureGroups resisting dominant culture through style
Punk, mods, rockers, etc.
Style = symbolic resistance
Eventually recuperated by mainstream (commodified)
Popular CultureMass culture = NOT just commercial manipulation
Site of negotiation, resistance
People make meanings actively
Complex, not simply imposed from above
IdeologySystems of belief serving power
Naturalize the constructed
Make contingent seem inevitable
Cultural studies unmasks ideology
ArticulationHall's term: linking elements together
Culture = articulated elements, not fixed unity
Can be rearticulated differently
Political struggle = struggle over articulation

Objects of Study

CategoryExamples
MediaTelevision, film, advertising, news, social media
Popular FormsRomance novels, detective fiction, science fiction, comics, fan fiction
SubculturesYouth cultures, punk, hip-hop, gaming communities
Everyday PracticesShopping, fashion, food, tourism, sports fandom
IdentityRace, gender, sexuality, class, nation - how constructed/represented
TechnologyDigital culture, internet, mobile media

Cultural Studies vs. Traditional Literary Criticism

Traditional Literary CriticismCultural Studies
"High" literature onlyAll cultural forms - popular, mass, elite
Aesthetic value primaryCultural/political significance primary
Canon of great worksNo canon; all texts worthy of study
Text-centered (New Criticism)Context-centered; production/consumption
Apolitical (claimed)Explicitly political; power relations
Single discipline (English)Interdisciplinary
Close readingCultural analysis; ethnography; discourse analysis

Cultural Studies - Significance & Critique

AchievementCritique
Democratized StudyLegitimized popular culture, working-class experienceAbandoned aesthetic judgment?
Political EngagementLinked scholarship to social justice, activismToo politicized; propaganda?
InterdisciplinaryBroke down disciplinary barriersLacks disciplinary rigor?
Active AudienceRecognized audience agency, resistanceOverestimated resistance?
Identity PoliticsAnalyzed race, gender, class, sexualityFragmented politics?
SpreadFrom Britain to USA, globally; transformed humanities

MCQ RAPID FIRE

QuestionAnswer
Ecocriticism emergence1990s; term by Cheryll Glotfelty; ASLE 1992
Ecocriticism definition"Study of relationship between literature and physical environment"
The Ecocriticism ReaderCheryll Glotfelty (ed.), 1996 - established field
Anthropocentrism vs. EcocentrismHuman-centered vs. Ecology-centered worldview
First wave ecocriticism1990s - nature writing, wilderness, Romantic tradition, USA-focused
Second wave ecocriticism2000s+ - urban, global, environmental justice, postcolonial
Environmental justiceEnvironmental racism, toxicity, intersectionality (race/class/environment)
Cultural Studies origins1960s Britain - Birmingham CCCS (1964)
Birmingham CCCS foundersRichard Hoggart, Stuart Hall, Raymond Williams
"Culture is ordinary"Raymond Williams - culture = everyday life, not elite
Structure of FeelingRaymond Williams - shared social experience of time/place; lived, affective
Stuart Hall's modelEncoding/Decoding - three positions: Dominant, Negotiated, Oppositional
HegemonyGramsci - consent-based rule; common sense = hegemonic ideology
SubcultureGroups resisting through style (punk, mods); studied by Hebdige
Cultural Studies focusALL cultural forms (popular, mass); power relations; working-class culture